18.08.26, Bar Peleg & Ran Shimoni, Haaretz
The move expands eligibility criteria after years of legal challenges over the state’s failure to process asylum requests, and is expected to grant status to most Sudanese asylum seekers still living in Israel without legal status
Israel has decided to grant temporary legal status to most Sudanese asylum seekers who have lived in the country for more than a decade and whose asylum applications have gone unprocessed, expanding eligibility criteria after years of prolonged state delays in processing asylum applications that left thousands in legal limbo.
The decision, made by the director general of the Population and Immigration Authority on Sunday, will apply to asylum seekers from Darfur, the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile who have lived continuously in Israel for more than a decade, submitted an asylum application more than a year ago and have yet to receive an answer, provided they have no criminal record or security-related impediment.
The state disclosed the decision Monday in response to a petition filed in the Tel Aviv District Court by a Sudanese asylum seeker who entered Israel through the Egyptian border in 2011 and has lived in Nazareth ever since. Because the eligibility criteria have now been expanded, his petition is expected to be withdrawn.
The move broadens previous eligibility criteria for temporary residency and comes after a series of court rulings criticizing the state’s prolonged failure to decide asylum claims. According to refugee rights organizations, about 1,800 Sudanese asylum seekers currently remain in Israel without legal status, while thousands of others have already received temporary residency following previouscourt rulings or policy changes.
For decades, Israel did not rule on asylum applications submitted by Sudanese nationals who fled to the country. In 2021, the High Court of Justice ruled that, because of the state’s prolonged delays – with some applications having remained pending for more than a decade – Sudanese asylum seekers should be granted temporary residency as a remedy for the systemic failure to adjudicate claims within a reasonable timeframe.
The court gave the state the option of individually deciding the asylum requests of 2,445 Sudanese applicants instead, but it failed to do so, and they ultimately received temporary residency under the ruling. A district court later extended the same status to about 1,000 asylum seekers from Darfur, and last year, then-Interior Minister Moshe Arbel broadened the eligibility criteria again, leading to temporary residency for roughly 200 additional applicants.
Sudanese nationals remain in Israel under temporary protection because of conditions in Sudan and the difficulty of deporting them. Although most have not been formally recognized as refugees, court rulings have enabled many to obtain temporary residency, allowing them to live and work legally in Israel and receive basic social benefits, subject to periodic renewal.
The status also grants access to health insurance, a driver’s license and a travel document permitting holders to leave and re-enter Israel. However, unlike full refugee status, it is temporary and must be renewed regularly.
According to refugee rights organizations, those who still have not submitted asylum applications are likely to include elderly people, younger migrants and others who lack access to legal aid organizations.
The latest policy change follows two recent District Court rulings ordering the state to grant temporary residency to three asylum seekers whose applications had remained pending for years. In those rulings, Judge Michal Agmon-Gonnen held that the prolonged delays had deprived the applicants of rights they might have enjoyed had their claims been decided within a reasonable time.
Those rulings departed from the prevailing approach, under which courts generally instructed the Population and Immigration Authority only to decide the applications without granting interim status. Earlier this month, however, the Supreme Court overturned one of Agmon-Gonen’s rulings involving an Eritrean asylum seeker whose application had been pending for eight years, finding that while the state is obligated to decide asylum applications within a reasonable time, delays alone do not justify granting legal status.
Michal Pomerantz, the petitioner’s attorney, welcomed the government’s decision.
“After a decade of litigation over residency status for Sudanese asylum seekers and several significant court rulings on the issue, I am pleased that the Population and Immigration Authority has once again expanded the criteria for eligibility,” she said. “It is just a shame that multiple legal proceedings were required for this purpose – including multiple petitions and district court proceedings.”