The Young Asylum Seekers Wishing to Join the Israeli Army, in Exchange for a Sense of Belonging

30.09.24, Gal Gabai, Haaretz

Asylum Seeker Community

Children and adolescents

Israeli government policy

The current war – with its multiple fronts and a shortage of some 10,000 troops due to ultra-Orthodox draft-dodging and general burnout – has prompted Israel to take surprising steps with regard to the country’s asylum seekers.

This is perhaps most overtly reflected in a plan, currently being advanced by Interior Minister Moshe Arbel and his team, to enlist young asylum seekers in the Israeli army in exchange for permanent residency status.
As per the plan, local authorities would locate the young asylum seekers, the IDF’s Manpower Directorate and the Interior Ministry would recruit them, and at the conclusion of basic training they would receive a permanent resident status.
Close to 30,000 African asylum seekers, mainly from Eritrea, reside in Israel; 8,700 of them are children and teenagers. It is estimated that some 5,000 of them were born in Israel, but none have legal status in the country, leaving them in existential insecurity. By refusing to define them as refugees, Israel is renouncing its international commitments. At the same time, it cannot deport them due to those same obligations.
An entire generation that sees itself as Israeli in every sense has grown up here, even though Israel isn’t interested in their presence. In Israel, where belonging is bought with blood and the army is the threshold to being accepted into society, these Israelis want to give more than the state is willing to take. Perhaps the emerging plan will change this picture.

Authorities turn a blind eye

Arayim Timi Yaman grew up in Israel and went to school here, but at 18 she discovered she wasn’t like everyone. “I want to contribute,” she says. “I want to participate, and when all my classmates enlist in the army, it gives me the strength to insist on [also doing] it. It’s insulting that the state tells me I’m not part of society.”

In December, Arayim, who is dreaming of serving in the Border Police, sent a letter to the president, the education minister, the Interior Ministry’s director general and to the director of the education division in the Tel Aviv municipality. “I live in Kfar Shalem, I went to Hashita kindergarten in Tel Aviv. I studied at Hayarden elementary school and in junior high I went to Ort Singalovski. This year I’m completing 12th grade and I need your help,” she wrote. “I want to contribute, and, like all my friends, to join the army. I don’t know any other state and this is my country. I’m asking [to be able to pursue] a path of life like any Israeli, and not to feel rejected only because I’m of Eritrean descent.”

Arayim’s father, Braha, says none of the officials answered the letter. “You’ve been sent a letter, so answer. ‘No’ is also an answer,” he says. “What, aren’t we human beings?” The lack of response becomes especially painful over time. “My friends are getting drafted in four months,” says Arayim. “Don’t give me an ID card, but at least let me enlist with them. It hurts.”
The decision not to decide deeply impacts the lives of youngsters like Arayim. Even before basic rights, there’s a fundamental need for belonging, the absence of which harms a person’s sense of personal security, self-esteem and personal identity. “We, the parents, aren’t asking for an ID card, only to let the children be part of it,” says Braha. “They grew up here, in Israeli culture, with Israeli values. We have no other state, and now they’re leaving them to shut themselves up at home and stay behind.”

Fanan Solomon, 21, came to Israel as a toddler and spent her childhood and youth hiding and denying her Eritrean identity, in a bid to prove to those around her she was Israeli. “I was mostly thought to be Ethiopian, so I went along with it. I didn’t want to make the difference any deeper than my skin color.”

She grew up in Bnei Brak, and in junior high began to grow closer to Judaism. “I was a member of Bnei Akiva [a religious youth movement] and then became a guide in the movement. I taught Jewish values, modesty, Torah and work,” she says. “The bottom line is I’m Israeli and nobody can dispute that. So while it’s true that I don’t have an ID card, I’m Israeli through and through.”

In high school, Fanan joined the Aharai! (After Me) youth program. “It’s a youth movement that prepares you for combat fitness and a meaningful army service,” she says. “I didn’t know what would happen. My friends had already received their first call-up and knew where they wanted to go.”
“At the end of 12th grade there was a year of thinking – what should I do in order to get drafted. I tried talking to my counsellors in Aharai to help me join a Nativ course [a conversion course to Judaism for soldiers] and convert through the army. I was obsessed. I’m very suitable for the army framework, even today. I’m tough enough to fulfill all the demands and requirements and adapt socially as well,” she adds.

Fanan also signed up for a mechina – a pre-army education and training program. “I dreamed of being in Oketz (the Israel Defense Forces’ canine unit),” she says, smiling. “I really imagined myself there. I thought if I went to the mechina, someone would see and understand and help me enlist.” She finished the program, but it wasn’t enough.

The desire of these youngsters to enlist is especially poignant given that their families escaped from war. Fanan’s father had been forcibly drafted into the army in Eritrea and fled. Now, in Israel, his daughter dreams of wearing a uniform. “There’s no experience more Israeli than joining the army, for better or worse,” she says. “You can be the most bummed out soldier and feel insignificant, but in the end that’s what connects you. You get up in the morning and put on an IDF uniform. I thought it was the best way to prove I’m Israeli.”

Roval Dionan, 20, grew up in south Tel Aviv. There were no Israeli citizens in his school. Like everyone else, he too had dreams. “In elementary school and junior high, when I’d see a soldier, my eyes would go wide open. You see an amazing person,” he says. “I dreamed of being in a special unit, the police commando or one of the reconnaissance commandos. I planned to enlist and raise a family here.”

Roval financed his studies at the Wingate Institute and received a fitness coach certificate. However, since he cannot work in this profession because the state won’t grant him a police clearance certificate, he works as a cook in a restaurant. But his dream of enlisting in the army hasn’t disappeared. “If they let me, I’m joining up right away,” he says. “Permanent residency status? I want a ‘belonging’ status. It gives you stability – not just physically, but mentally.”
As one who sees his future in Israel, he volunteers in two community aid organizations. “There’s a chance for a change that will help the younger generation too, which is full of potential and abilities,” he says. “I believe that if the state gives us, the youngsters, a chance, it will gain people who can contribute, especially now.”
Fanan says the struggle to draft the ultra-Orthodox men and their obstinate objection, especially at a time of war, deepens her feeling of rejection. “They say they’re short of soldiers, so why go to people who don’t want to enlist when right here they have a whole bunch of people [who do]? An entire generation that was born and raised in Israel and has no possibility of going anywhere else, nor a connection to anywhere else, and that wants to enlist,” she says. “We want to be drafted with no conditions. It’s part of the Israeli experience. I feel it’s my duty, irrespective of an ID card and residency status.”

The international conventions Israel has signed oblige it to enable asylum seekers’ children to go to school. At 18, they graduate and find themselves in a social void, pushed to the margins, with no basic rights. At this stage, sometimes for the first time, they really understand the meaning of detachment and displacement.

Money to leave the country
This is what happened to Peleg Tahlai, 26, who, after 12 years of school in central Tel Aviv, found herself unmoored. The transition from life in Israeli society, complex as it was, to its margins, triggered a deeply unsettling crisis for her. Today, she is fighting to prevent her brothers and future generations from facing the same hardship.
“Every time I go to renew my visa, I see the sign in which the state offers me money to leave voluntarily, and every time I cry,” she says. “If in daily life you forget your situation, the sign reminds you: You’re not wanted, you don’t belong. I grew up here from a young age, all I know is Israel. But they take away your rights and impose so many restrictions on you, they exert every possible pressure to drive you away from here. It makes you depressed.”
The first time Peleg felt this was in high school in Ramat Aviv. “Everyone went on a trip to learn about the Holocaust, and suddenly they told me I couldn’t go because I’m not Israeli and we’re not allowed to leave the country and reenter it,” she says. “Everyone went and I stayed behind.”
Fanan remembers the sharp transition clearly. “For years I was surrounded by counsellors, teachers, friends, and suddenly a cut – all the ties disappear,” she says. “It was a difficult period. I grew up here, I love Judaism, I was a counsellor… and then simply remained behind. All my friends moved forward together, wore uniforms, and I’m stuck in one place.
“At first I was angry. How can you leave me behind? But it’s not their fault, it’s not in their hands. They also insisted that I go with them to a Nahal program group. Today they’re serving with [the Nahal brigade’s] green beret and I’m a guide in the Noar HaOved youth movement in Rishon Lezion,” says Fanan.
The effort to belong generates ways to contribute outside the military framework. “I grew up here, the only world I know is here, so I’m not going to sit idly,” says Peleg, who had dreamed of serving as a navy combatant. “I contribute in ways that don’t require an ID card. I volunteer in NGOs that collect clothes, preserves and socks for soldiers – for that I don’t need the government’s permission.”

She knows that at her age the chances of enlisting are diminishing. “But if they offer, of course I’ll enlist. Especially in the current situation,” she says. “With or without an ID card, I want to defend the country I live in, where my brothers and family are.”

Fanan feels helpless. “Since the beginning of the war I ask myself, how is it that I’m not in the army? How am I not giving [of myself] to the state at this time? All my friends are fighting and risking their lives and I’m sitting at home,” she says.

Haaretz’s report this month about the defense establishment offering asylum seekers assistance in receiving permanent legal status in exchange for participation in life-threatening operations in Gaza sparked sharp criticism. But what do asylum seekers who are eager to enlist think about it?

“Maybe to someone neutral it would seem like exploitation,” says Fanan. “But from an early age I dreamed of joining the army, to do my part for the state and then to be Israeli. It’s my dream. [But] whoever doesn’t feel this lack of belonging can see it as exploitation, that those who don’t have legal status have no other choice.”

“Our community fled from war, so it’s a sensitive issue,” says Peleg. “To tell someone, come, we’ll throw you out in the field and if you return you may get an ID card – that’s like going to the weakest, most defenseless link. But if they’ll take care of the Eritrean and Israeli soldiers equally, then it makes sense.”
As they move further away from the draft age of 18, hope shrinks and despair grows. “Most of the Eritrean community have no hope for the future,” says Fanan. “I feel cut off. On the one hand, I live a full life and on the other hand, I have no life. I have so many restrictions that I have nowhere to go. It’s a state that doesn’t like me and doesn’t want me and won’t let me live here, really live.
“My feelings and actions don’t have any significance as far as the state and society are concerned. My most distant future is tomorrow, because there’s no certainty. I’m trying to build a foundation for myself, one of earth that I can stand on, but instead it’s made of paper.”
Original article
Back to top